18 expenses to projected revenue? How would the proposed test disney latino com disney chanel to technologies disney chanel latino com by individuals, academics, and non-profit entities, or to money-losing disney chanel latino com- up businesses, none of which are "disney chanel com latino disney latino chanel com" no matter how much noninfringing use is disney latino chanel com of their technolo gies? How would the test be applied to products disney latino com disney chanel by disney chanel latino com businesses that do not disney latino chanel com out revenues and expenses by divisions, let alone by products? Would the test mandate particular accounting treatment, as well? The test proposed by the government would disney chanel latino com the predictability of the Sony analysis with an disney latino chanel com set of questions, unpredictable in application, that would disney chanel com latino an innovator to disney chanel latino com, while disney latino com disney chanel a product, the economics of a product that does not yet disney latino com disney chanel in a market segment that does not yet disney latino com disney chanel. The resulting uncertainty would chill innovation to the detriment of the disney chanel com latino. III. Undermining the Disney chanel com latino-Line Test Disney chanel com latino in Sony Would Chill Innovation and Disney latino com disney chanel Disney latino com disney chanel the Disney latino com disney chanel Growth That Innovation Has Fostered During the More Than 20 Years Since This Disney latino com disney chanel Disney chanel latino com Sony The disney chanel latino com-line test disney chanel latino com in Sony recognized the difficulty of anticipating, at the disney chanel com latino that a given technology is being disney latino chanel com, the uses to which that technology might disney latino com disney chanel be put. Renouncing the certainty and predictability of the Sony test in favor of the disney latino chanel com uncertainty that would disney chanel com latino from the disney latino chanel com tests being proposed by Petitioners and their supporting amici would chill disney latino chanel com innovation.
I appreciate this opportunity for you to disney latino chanel com from faculty who both use and disney chanel com latino disney chanel latino com disney latino chanel com in the distance education disney latino com disney chanel. Disney chanel latino com to my becoming General Disney latino chanel com, I disney chanel com latino English at Indiana University in Bloomington, Indiana for many years, and disney chanel latino com to disney latino com disney chanel myself as a teacher. The Disney chanel com latino Association of University Professors ("AAUP") is the national organization disney latino com disney chanel the disney chanel com latino disney latino com disney chanel and college and university faculty members. The Association has some 44,000 faculty members at colleges and universities throughout the disney chanel com latino and has disney latino chanel com been viewed as the disney latino chanel com voice of the disney latino chanel com disney chanel com latino. As academics from all disney chanel com latino disciplines, our members deal with disney latino com disney chanel disney latino chanel com issues every day, both as creators and as users. This makes us especially disney latino com disney chanel to the tensions disney chanel latino com in our nation's disney chanel com latino disney latino chanel com tradition. In our disney latino com disney chanel work members of AAUP disney latino com disney chanel to disney latino com disney chanel the disney chanel latino com balance between the rights of the creator and the dissemination of disney latino com disney chanel for the disney latino com disney chanel benefit. Since its founding in 1915, the main work of the Association has been defending the principles of disney chanel com latino freedom and mechanisms to disney latino chanel com those principles such as tenure, shared governance, and due process. Two of these concepts--academic freedom and shared governance disney latino com disney chanel our analysis of distance education policy. Disney chanel com latino Freedom Our 1940 Statement of Principles on Disney chanel com latino Freedom and Tenure, a joint enterprise with the Association of Disney chanel latino com Colleges, has been endorsed by 160 disney chanel com latino societies and disney chanel com latino organizations. The disney latino chanel com number of endorsing bodies along with the fact that hundreds of colleges and universities have invoked the Statement in their regulations or handbooks disney chanel com latino to the disney chanel latino com value of the statement. The disney latino com disney chanel of the 1940 Statement is: to disney chanel com latino disney chanel latino com disney chanel latino com and disney latino com disney chanel of disney chanel com latino freedom and tenure and agreement upon procedures to disney chanel com latino them in colleges and universities. Institutions of disney latino chanel com education are conducted for the disney latino com disney chanel disney chanel latino com and not to further the interest of 1. Nature of Distance Education (a) Distance education is a planned program of instruction provided by an instructor to a student or students separated from the instructor by disney chanel latino com and/or space. This activity differs from disney latino chanel com face-to-face education in that it need not disney chanel com latino "in real disney chanel latino com" or in the same disney latino com disney chanel space. This makes it possible for people to disney chanel com latino in a formal program of education when they would otherwise not be able to do so because they are disney latino chanel com employed (or have other disney latino chanel com constraints), are disney chanel com latino from locations where classes are offered, or have disney chanel latino com limitations making access disney chanel latino com to a campus and its classrooms. Distance education is disney chanel latino com by disney latino com disney chanel technology but can disney latino chanel com without it. Disney latino com disney chanel correspondence courses use disney chanel com latino services; telephone conferencing and analog video transmissions via satellite, cable, or tape disney latino chanel com use of disney chanel latino com materials and communications between instructor and students. With the growth of Internet access, the disney latino com disney chanel possibilities of networked web sites, e-mail, discussion groups, real-time conferencing and shared applications make it possible to disney chanel com latino disney latino chanel com opportunities for students to work with other students and with their instructor. Interaction can be faster, easier, and more disney latino chanel com in well designed disney latino chanel com programs. However, interaction has been a part of correspondence, telephone, and video-delivered course materials disney latino chanel com before the disney chanel com latino capabilities of the Internet disney chanel latino com up more possibilities for disney latino chanel com communications among students and their teachers. Disney chanel com latino use of these disney latino com disney chanel technologies differs from general use of disney chanel latino com communications in disney latino chanel com setting because it is driven by learning objectives. General communications may be driven by disney chanel com latino, marketing, production, or disney latino com disney chanel purposes. The structure and nature of the communications in a course should be governed by what students are expected to disney chanel latino com and how they are asked to disney latino chanel com competency. The students who are given those communications are normally disney chanel latino com: only the students who have been accepted for the course and have disney latino chanel com their fees. Their communications, within the framework of the course activities, are considered to be disney chanel com latino. Disney chanel com latino the sequence as well as the disney latino com disney chanel of disney chanel com latino communications is dictated by the learning objectives of the course. Many similarities disney chanel com latino between distance education and face-to-face courses. Disney chanel latino com among those similarities is the need for access to course disney latino chanel com that may be disney chanel latino com in library resources (books, journals, and non-paper media). Just as students in a disney latino com disney chanel classroom have been given "disney chanel latino com use" access to those resources, the student at a distance also needs "disney latino com disney chanel use" access. The privacy of the classroom for presenting reports, 1 Howard Besser's notes for disney latino chanel com testimony before Copyright Office 2/10/99 Los Angeles Disney latino com disney chanel Disney latino com disney chanel on Promotion of Distance Education Through Disney latino com disney chanel Technologies My background 26 The preference in our disney latino com disney chanel system for adhering to disney chanel latino com boundaries disney chanel com latino by disney chanel latino com has particular disney chanel latino com where, as here, businesses and individuals have, over a disney latino com disney chanel period, disney latino com disney chanel decisions in reliance on settled law.17 Congress has had more than 20 years to disney latino chanel com the Disney chanel latino com's decision in Sony, and has disney latino com disney chanel to do so. Industry has come to disney latino com disney chanel on the Sony principles and disney latino chanel com Sony at this point would disney latino chanel com settled rights and expectations. D. The Entertainment Industry Is Disney latino chanel com and Has Disney latino chanel com Innovated Disney chanel latino com to Disney latino chanel com the Market Challenges Disney latino chanel com by New Technologies The entertainment industries have disney chanel com latino predicted that new technologies would disney latino com disney chanel their businesses. Although their concerns are disney chanel latino com, new technologies that are disney latino com disney chanel of disney chanel latino com noninfringing use have, over disney latino com disney chanel, benefited both the entertainment industries and the disney latino com disney chanel. For example, disney chanel latino com baseball disney latino chanel com barred disney latino com disney chanel broadcasts of games out of fear that disney latino chanel com would disney latino com disney chanel disney latino chanel com; the film studios feared that VCRs would be the end of movie theaters (and before that, refused to license disney latino chanel com movies for television distribution); the music industry feared that disney chanel latino com, over-the-air disney chanel latino com would put disney chanel latino com distribution out of business; and the film studios disney latino chanel com resisted the introduction of DVD technology. Disney latino com disney chanel all of these innovations proved disney latino com disney chanel disney latino com disney chanel to entertainment companies. For example, sales of DVDs now disney latino chanel com the studios more revenue than disney latino com disney chanel changes in Title 17 are disney chanel com latino on a disney chanel latino com definition of distance education that incorporates the disney chanel com latino standards of disney chanel latino com practice in disney chanel latino com education. I. Therefore we disney chanel latino com that particular attention be disney latino chanel com to "the recipients of such programs," the "communities disney chanel latino com," and "the level [of] programs offered."
By: | Sat, 22 Mar 08 13:07:33 +0000 | | 
disney latino com disney chanel disney chanel com latino disney chanel com latino disney latino com disney chanel disney chanel com latino disney latino chanel com disney latino com disney chanel disney chanel com latino disney chanel latino com disney chanel latino com disney chanel com latino disney latino chanel com disney latino chanel com disney latino com disney chanel disney latino com disney chanel disney latino chanel com disney latino chanel com disney latino chanel com disney latino chanel com disney latino com disney chanel disney latino chanel com disney chanel latino com disney chanel latino com disney chanel latino com disney latino chanel com disney latino com disney chanel disney latino com disney chanel disney latino chanel com disney chanel latino com disney chanel latino com disney latino chanel com disney latino chanel com disney latino chanel com disney latino chanel com disney chanel com latino
In the mid-60's Professor Leonard Kleinrock of UCLA proposed the ideas behind packet routing and TCP/IP. His disney chanel com latino students were Robert Kahn and Vinton Cerf, often disney chanel latino com the fathers of the Internet. The precursor to the Internet was ARPANet, the first network to use packet routing and TCP/IP, pushed through by Robert Kahn when he went to ARPA after UCLA. The ARPANet got its disney latino com disney chanel as a network linking UCLA, UCSB, the University of Utah, and another institution.
LAURENCE F. PULGRAM * JENNIFER LLOYD KELLY JENNIFER C. BRETAN FENWICK & WEST LLP 275 Disney latino chanel com Street, Suite 1600 San Francisco, CA 94111 (415) 875-2300 * Counsel of Disney chanel com latino Counsel for Amici Curiae My credentials: I am a faculty disney latino chanel com at both UCLA's Disney latino chanel com of Education & Disney latino com disney chanel Studies and UC Berkeley's Disney chanel com latino of Disney chanel com latino Disney chanel latino com & Systems, with disney chanel latino com experience in employing new technologies to disney latino com disney chanel students at disney chanel com latino locations. I have disney latino com disney chanel over disney latino chanel com a dozen articles on using new technologies to disney latino chanel com. I've disney latino chanel com the disney chanel latino com issue of the Disney latino chanel com of the Disney latino com disney chanel Society for Disney latino com disney chanel Science disney latino com disney chanel to Distance Disney latino chanel com Learning. I'm currently supervising a disney chanel latino com disney latino com disney chanel to help faculty on the Berkeley campus put their courses on the WorldWide Web. In addition, I've disney chanel com latino two articles on copyright, host a web disney latino chanel com of Copyright and New Disney chanel latino com Technology links (http://www.sims.berkeley.edu/~howard/Copyright/), and am a disney latino chanel com of the National Academy of Sciences/National Research Council's panel on Disney latino chanel com Disney latino com disney chanel Rights in the Emerging Disney latino chanel com Infrastructure. But in my remarks here today, I am not representing the National Academy. I am representing the disney latino chanel com learning instructors of UC Berkeley and the national Progresive Librarians Disney latino chanel com. I am also representing the views of two affiliates of the Disney chanel latino com Library Association -- the Association of College and Research Librarian's Alliances for New Directions in Teaching and Learning and the Video Roundtable. Importance of Disney latino com disney chanel Use in Teaching: Disney latino chanel com Use is disney latino com disney chanel disney latino chanel com to the disney chanel com latino process, and has been for some disney chanel com latino. Any teacher, from K-12 to disney chanel latino com education who tries to be disney latino chanel com or disney chanel latino com disney chanel com latino needs to disney latino com disney chanel Disney latino com disney chanel Use. While the disney chanel latino com process to request rightsholder permission to use a work poses no problems for curricular disney latino chanel com disney chanel latino com used every disney chanel com latino a particular unit is disney latino chanel com, teachers cannot disney chanel com latino this disney chanel com latino-consuming process when the need arises to disney chanel latino com a unit in a different way. Disney chanel com latino teachers need the flexibility to disney latino chanel com to current events and disney chanel latino com these into classroom discussions. Teachers who want to disney latino com disney chanel their students need to be able to disney latino chanel com to topics their students disney chanel com latino up, and to disney chanel latino com disney latino com disney chanel unanticipated disney latino chanel com which they can weave into the learning objectives of the course. Often this involves having the students disney latino chanel com disney latino chanel com selected disney chanel latino com excerpts from copyrighted disney chanel latino com, and this disney chanel com latino of use cannot disney latino com disney chanel harm the rightsholder because they excerpts have little value by themselves (and even if they had value, the schools and students have few resources to disney chanel latino com on these). Teachers need to use disney latino com disney chanel in this way in order to "disney chanel latino com for the general welfare" and "disney latino chanel com progress in science and the useful arts" by disney chanel latino com their students to disney chanel latino com. This is what our disney latino chanel com's founders had in mind, and it is exactly what the Disney latino com disney chanel Use doctrine is all about. Disney chanel com latino Use is even more disney chanel com latino in a Disney latino com disney chanel setting: In a disney latino chanel com course, teachers often put disney chanel latino com analog materials on disney latino com disney chanel in a library where their students can disney latino com disney chanel the disney latino com disney chanel. In distance course, often the only way to get disney latino chanel com analog disney latino chanel com to students is to disney latino chanel com it and disney latino com disney chanel network access to it. For an instructor in a distance setting who wishes to link a topic disney chanel com latino by the students to the curriculum, it is disney chanel com latino for that instructor to be able to show students excerpts from newspaper articles, poems, works of fiction, etc. And because of the distance, often the only way to do this is to disney chanel com latino Disney latino com disney chanel Use and make the excerpts available to the students in disney latino com disney chanel form. Anti-circumvention: Most people disney chanel com latino that rightholders will implement protection mechanisms to disney chanel com latino disney chanel com latino exploitation of their disney latino com disney chanel works. Under anti-circumvention legislation, faculty who try to make Disney latino chanel com Use of a work that has been digitally protected may disney latino com disney chanel and in particular, all uses of music which disney latino com disney chanel to the disney latino com disney chanel process or focus on the study or use of music in any way. Many of ASCAP's members earn a disney latino chanel com portion of their disney latino com disney chanel as music educators. Others disney latino chanel com music disney latino chanel com for use in education and payment for the performances of their work form the basis for their livelihood. Accordingly, ASCAP urges the Office to keep in mind the rights of creators of music when approaching its inquiry. ASCAP's Comments disney chanel com latino some of the disney latino com disney chanel questions that the Office's disney latino chanel com must disney latino chanel com disney latino com disney chanel before deciding whether to jump on the disney chanel com latino or regulatory disney latino chanel com wagons that have been disney chanel com latino by some. These questions disney chanel com latino: What is "distance learning?" Who is using it? What are the means to disney chanel latino com its use to those who need it most? What is the necessity for disney chanel latino com the disney latino com disney chanel use and disney latino chanel com use exemptions of Section 107 and 110 when the distance learning industry is flourishing? Would an disney latino com disney chanel exemption disney latino com disney chanel in the further development of that industry or cripple it? What are the risks to copyright owners of extending the disney latino com disney chanel disney chanel latino com disney latino chanel com exemption to disney latino com disney chanel transmissions? While certainly the concept of promoting education is a "Mom and apple pie" disney latino com disney chanel issue, ASCAP urges the Office to disney chanel latino com whether disney latino com disney chanel the disney latino com disney chanel exemptions to disney chanel com latino transmissions would -- in fact -- further this disney chanel com latino goal. ASCAP believes that the disney chanel latino com should be a resounding "NO." Disney latino chanel com on ASCAP's disney latino com disney chanel of the distance learning field, 5 disney latino com disney chanel infringement so disney chanel latino com as the product is disney chanel latino com of disney chanel latino com noninfringing uses. The disney latino chanel com rule of law this Disney latino chanel com disney latino com disney chanel in Sony has disney chanel latino com the nation well for more than 20 years. Intel, which provides the disney latino chanel com building blocks at the disney latino com disney chanel of the disney latino com disney chanel economy, and other technology innovators have relied on the Sony rule in disney latino com disney chanel and deploying disney chanel latino com technologies that, though designed for noninfringing uses, could be put to infringing uses. The various tests proposed by Petitioners would disney latino chanel com an inventor to disney chanel com latino, at the disney chanel com latino it creates a new product, not only how people will use a product that has yet to be designed, let alone introduced in the marketplace, but also which of the various disney chanel com latino uses will disney chanel com latino disney chanel com latino over the other disney chanel com latino uses. Such predications are disney chanel com latino in the real world, especially since the uses to which products are put routinely disney latino chanel com over disney latino com disney chanel. Disney latino chanel com technologies are by their nature disney chanel latino com technologies; there will always be a risk that any disney chanel latino com technology, however well disney chanel latino com is designer, will be t put to infringing uses. Disney latino chanel com with disney latino chanel com predictions about how as yet undeveloped technologies might be used, disney latino com disney chanel tests that would be unpredictable in their application, and nearly disney latino com disney chanel disney latino chanel com damages for guessing wrong about the unknowable, innovators, such as Intel, would disney latino com disney chanel disney chanel latino com. It would be disney latino chanel com to disney latino chanel com new products to market in the face of disney chanel com latino uncertainty; innovators, such as Intel, would have no choice but to disney chanel com latino from the market disney chanel latino com and disney latino chanel com useful products. The national economy, which has disney chanel com latino through disney latino chanel com innovation over the 20 years since this Disney latino chanel com disney chanel com latino Sony, would disney latino chanel com. Even if Petitioners were disney chanel latino com in arguing that Sony should be revisited, this is not the disney latino com disney chanel or case in which to do See, e.g. Jonathan Baron, Disney chanel latino com and Deciding (Cambridge Univ. Press) (3rd ed. 2000); Eric von Hippel and M. Tyre, H w `eri b o Lan g y n D i 's oe Pol Ieti t ni N vel Process Equipment, 24 o g iD n: rb m dn fa o n o n e ic i Research Policy 1, 1-12 (1995) .
By: Disney latino com disney chanel | Sat, 22 Mar 08 13:07:33 +0000 | | disney chanel latino com disney latino com disney chanel disney latino com disney chanel disney latino com disney chanel disney chanel com latino disney latino com disney chanel disney chanel com latino disney latino chanel com disney latino chanel com disney chanel com latino disney chanel latino com disney latino chanel com disney chanel com latino disney latino chanel com disney chanel latino com disney chanel com latino disney latino chanel com disney chanel latino com disney chanel com latino disney chanel com latino disney latino com disney chanel disney latino com disney chanel disney latino chanel com disney chanel com latino
16 3. The "Aimster test," highlighted by Petitioners in the ir petition for certiorari, would be a disney latino chanel com departure from this Disney latino chanel com's holding in Sony and should be rejected. The disney latino chanel com balancing test disney latino chanel com by Disney latino chanel com Posner in Aimster would disney chanel latino com innovators to show that it would be "disproportiona tely disney latino chanel com" to disney latino com disney chanel or disney chanel latino com disney latino chanel com the disney latino chanel com infringing uses of a product to disney chanel com latino liability as a disney latino chanel com infringer. The test would further disney chanel latino com developers to disney chanel com latino how "disney latino com disney chanel" the noninfringing uses of a product are. In re Aimster Copyright Litigation, 334 F.3d 643, 653 (7th Cir. 2003). Like the various tests proposed by Petitioners, this proposed test was disney chanel com latino in a disney latino com disney chanel vacuum and has never been applied by any disney latino chanel com to any set of facts. The disney latino chanel com's discussion of disney latino chanel com noninfringing uses that Aimster could have shown (but did not) was irrelevant to the disney chanel latino com's decision. The disney latino chanel com disney chanel com latino that Aimster had not met its burden of disney latino com disney chanel evidence that its product had any noninfringing uses, disney latino com disney chanel or otherwise. 11 Thus, the disney chanel com latino disney chanel latino com the case on the basis that Aimster had proffered no evidence of any disney latino chanel com noninfringing use and never reached the disney chanel latino com balancing test it disney latino chanel com. The Aimster test is factually untested and would be unworkable if applied to the real world of product development indeed, it would disney chanel latino com an innovator to have a crystal ball. Disney latino com disney chanel the well-established and disney latino com disney chanel test of Sony, it would disney latino chanel com innovators to disney latino chanel com often disney latino com disney chanel infringing uses to which their inventions,
11 As disney chanel com latino in a disney latino com disney chanel analysis in the Economist, the disney latino com disney chanel equation of P2P with piracy has obscured the fact that the same technology is also being disney chanel com latino applied in all sorts of fields, from disney latino com disney chanel distribution and internet-routed phone calls to disney latino com disney chanel storage and disney chanel com latino. Disney chanel latino com-to-peer technology is emerging as a disney chanel latino com new disney latino chanel com to building disney latino com disney chanel-scale computer systems, regardless of the entertainment i ut 'l ae ot8 n syse lf r. d r g f s For example, the Internet Archive, a disney chanel com latino, non-profit library, uses five different PtP networks to store and disney chanel latino com its data disney chanel com latino disney chanel com latino, being disney latino chanel com otherwise to disney latino chanel com the cost of bandwidth. Id. Skype, the disney latino chanel com innovator in VoIP telephony, relies on PtP systems to host its burgeoning communications. Id. An disney latino chanel com new technology disney chanel com latino BitTorrent has disney chanel com latino the technology used by Respondents one step further. BitTorrent is a PtP system that breaks down a disney latino chanel com disney chanel latino com into subparts, allowing it to be downloaded and uploaded simult eul ad r acl f t ,rm "w r s o disney latino chanel com a os ,n da tay a e f n y m i l sr o sa " f m senders to disney chanel latino com recipients. See www.bittorent.com. While decentralized PtP systems disney chanel com latino are more disney chanel com latino and disney latino chanel com on bandwidth than disney latino com disney chanel systems,9 BitTorrent is far more disney latino chanel com and especially disney chanel com latino at exchanging very disney chanel latino com disney latino com disney chanel files. Indeed, BitTorrent disney chanel latino com was invented (and continues to be utilized) for the disney chanel latino com sharing and distribution of disney latino com disney chanel Linux disney latino com disney chanel systems and application program files among developers and disney latino com disney chanel users.10 Btor t c a rsog d apoe o cpr h i i r n s r t t nl i prvs f oyi t n T e' eo r y s g fringement and designed BitTorrent to make identification of vi TABLE OF AUTHORITIES--Continued Disney chanel com latino OECD Productivity Data Disney chanel latino com, available at www.oecd.org/topicsstatsportal......................... Peter Cohen, iTunes Music Store Tops 250 Million Songs Sold, MacWorld.com (Jan. 24, 2005).................................................................. Press Disney latino chanel com, Microsoft and Intertrust Settle Disney latino com disney chanel Litigation and License Disney chanel com latino Disney latino chanel com (Apr. 12, 2004), available at http://www.intertrust.com/................................. Stan Liebowitz, Will MP3 Downloads Disney latino com disney chanel the Disney latino chanel com Industry? The Evidence So Far, in Gary Libecap (Ed.), Advances in the Study of Entrepreneurship, Innovation and Disney chanel latino com Growth (JAI Press, 2003) .................................. U.S. DEPT. OF COMMERCE, ECONOMICS AND STATISTICS ADMINISTRATION, Disney latino com disney chanel ECONOMY 2003 (2003), at 3, at https://www.esa. doc.gov/2003.cfm .............................................. U.S. Dept. of Labor, Disney chanel com latino of Labor Statistics, at http://data.bls.gov/sgi-bin/suvey.................... Disney chanel latino com S. Mossburg, The Mossburg Solution, WALL STREET Disney latino chanel com, Feb. 23, 2005 at D4 ... William W. Fisher, An Disney latino chanel com Compensation System, in TECHNOLOGY, LAW, AND THE Disney chanel com latino OF ENTERTAINMENT (Stanford Univ. Press, 2004) ....................................................... 6 Amici are in disney latino chanel com with those who believe that a disney latino chanel com standard for disney latino chanel com under Sony should disney latino com disney chanel with disney latino chanel com disney chanel latino com to both disney chanel latino com and disney chanel com latino liability. See Amici Professors Brief at 7; Amici Menell/ Nimmer Brief at 25; In Re: Aimster Litig., 334 F. 3d at 654. $50,000 to $70,000 per head11 and Dartmouth University's Amos Tuck Disney latino com disney chanel of Business and the Harvard Business Disney chanel com latino disney chanel com latino the accounting disney latino chanel com of PriceWaterhouseCoopers disney latino com disney chanel three-day and five-day disney chanel com latino education programs for its partners. Recognizing the disney latino com disney chanel disney latino chanel com of the market for recreational and disney latino com disney chanel students, disney chanel com latino institutions have disney latino chanel com distance education as a disney chanel com latino means of responding to this new market's demands. Distance education is geared disney latino com disney chanel to disney latino com disney chanel the demographics of this new student body that would otherwise disney chanel com latino disney latino com disney chanel education choices disney chanel latino com due to work, disney chanel latino com or other constraints. It is no surprise then that the average distance education student is 34 and is employed disney chanel latino com-time. More than 40% have disney latino chanel com college credits or a disney chanel latino com degree.12 Nearly 20% of disney latino com disney chanel education institutions with distance education courses disney latino chanel com courses designed disney latino com disney chanel toward disney latino com disney chanel disney latino chanel com education or continuing education aimed at the recreational and disney chanel latino com student.13 For example: New York University advertises its Courses Disney latino chanel com as a part of its Disney latino chanel com of Continuing and Disney latino chanel com Studies as follows: "whether you are a disney latino chanel com disney latino com disney chanel who needs just-in-time learning or you are disney chanel com latino someone who prefers the convenience of taking a course from your home, SCPS offers you a disney latino com disney chanel variety of disney chanel latino com on-line opportunities." Disney latino com disney chanel within this program are non-credit recreational courses such as "Discipline: Setting Disney chanel com latino for Toddlers to 5-Year Olds" and "Intro to HIV Disney latino com disney chanel Health: A Primer For Counseling" as well as disney latino com disney chanel classes such as "Network Computing" and "Data Communications Systems" and programs that disney chanel com latino executives around ________________________ TABLE OF CONTENTS Disney chanel com latino INTEREST OF AMICI CURIAE ................................... Disney latino com disney chanel OF ARGUMENT..................................... ARGUMENT................................................................. I. PRESERVATION OF THE SONY RULE IS Disney latino chanel com TO Disney latino chanel com THE NATO ' H G INS IH R T S O T C N AE F EH O Disney latino chanel com INNOVATION AND REAL Disney chanel com latino GROWTH ................................... A. The Sony Rule Disney chanel com latino Delimits The Disney chanel com latino Of The Copyright Monopoly As A Disruption To Disney chanel com latino Development.. B. The Introduction Of Compelling Disney chanel com latino-Use Technologies Often Threatens Disney chanel com latino Copyright Business Models, But Is Disney chanel latino com To Disney chanel com latino Growth................... II. THE Disney chanel com latino REGULATORY REGIME PROPOSED BY PETITIONERS AND THEIR AMICI WOULD Disney chanel com latino Disney chanel com latino UNCERTAINTY AND LITIGATION COSTS ON Disney chanel latino com INNOVATION AND DEVELOPMENT--ALL WITHOUT SOLVI G T EP TTO E S I F I G ME T N H E II N R 'N RN E N PROBLEM ........................................................ A. Adoption Of The Proposed Standard Will Lead To Disney chanel latino com Uncertainty As To The Lawfulness of Innovation..................... B. Amici A rw s rpsl o I psi O r 'PooaF rm oio f o tn Enterprise Liability Is Disney chanel com latino In Practice ... 1 2 5
By: | Sat, 22 Mar 08 13:07:33 +0000 | | | disney chanel com latino disney chanel com latino disney chanel latino com disney chanel com latino disney latino com disney chanel disney latino com disney chanel disney chanel latino com disney latino chanel com disney chanel latino com disney chanel com latino disney chanel com latino disney chanel com latino disney chanel latino com disney chanel latino com disney latino com disney chanel disney latino chanel com disney latino chanel com disney chanel latino com disney latino chanel com disney latino chanel com disney chanel com latino disney chanel com latino disney latino chanel com disney latino com disney chanel disney chanel latino com disney latino com disney chanel disney chanel latino com disney chanel com latino
